GSE logo

20th Century Folk
The First Generation

January 18, 1983 to March 12, 1983

Interest in American folk art may be divided into three distinct stages. The first began when American artists who had become familiar with folk art in Europe returned to this country after the first world war and stimulated an awareness of native exponents of the genre. Initially, activity centered on the folk art of the past, but by the 1930s the field had expanded to include contemporary examples. The second phase of folk art appreciation, which involved 20th-century artists, may be said to have begun when the paintings of construction worker John Kane were admitted to the Carnegie International in 1927. It continued through the 1930s, with such exhibitions as the Museum of Modern Art's Masters of Popular Painting, and peaked in the early 1940s, when discovering new “primitives” became almost a fad. An element of faddism still stigmatizes folk art, and serious advocates of the field must tread lightly to avoid being contaminated by the plethora of spurious or simply bad work. The third, present wave of folk art enthusiasm, like the first, concentrates on the art of the past. Twentieth-century folk art remains controversial, not entirely without justification. There have been rare artists like Grandma Moses who developed and sustained genuine original folk styles. There have also been those who developed, but could not sustain, original styles. And then there have been a host of imitators and pseudo-folk artists. The present exhibition contains many “also-rans,” members of the first generation of contemporary folk artists whose reputations vanished along with the second folk art boom. Their work has now, with the passage of time, become historical, and it is hoped that the exhibition will help place 20th-century folk art in perspective.

Josephine joy (1869-1948) Josephine Joy, like many of the artists in this exhibition, is one of the “forgotten primitives.” She began painting in 1927, after her husband died. Subsequent financial reverses forced her to seek employment with the WPA California Art Project. This, in turn, led to a number of local exhibitions. Eventually, her work was acquired by the Museum of Modern Art. Joy was included in Sidney Janis's pioneering book on 20th-century folk painting, They Taught Themselves (published in 1942), and in the 1981 exhibition “In Their Own Way,” at the National Museum of American Art, Smithsonian Institution.

Abraham Levin (1880-1957) Abraham Levin, like his better known compatriot Morris Hirshfield, emigrated to the United States from Lithuania and found employment in the garment industry. Bored, and eventually disgusted, with his mind-numbing job sewing “knee pants,” he started making pencil sketches and, at the age of 57, turned to painting. Encouraged by friends in the Bronx community where he lived, he brought his work to the Uptown Gallery in Manhattan, which gave him his first show in 1941. Several exhibitions at the Galerie St. Etienne followed in quick succession. Initially, Levin was hailed as a great “find;” the New York Times called his first exhibition “a thrilling experience.” Critics responded strongly to the elements of his intuitive style that evoked Cezanne, Braque and Chagall. The dovetailing of folk art and modernism, which in the early 1940s still seemed cogent, began to lose support as the decade progressed. In the end, Levin was forced to beg for his old job with the Amalgamated Clothing Workers.

Israel Litwak (b. 1868) Israel Litwak emigrated to the United States from Russia in 1903, the same year as Levin. Like most folk painters of his generation, he only took up painting late in life. At the age of 68, he was forced to retire from his job as a cabinet maker. Nevertheless, he felt compelled to work. “I had to do something,” he recalled. “Then all of a sudden, came out of me an artist.” Litwak's first one-man exhibition was held at the Brooklyn Museum in 1939. Like Joy, he was included in They Taught Themselves. Though less well known today than formerly, his colorful canvases remain as pleasing to the eye as they were when they were first painted.

Inez Mason (1898-1956) Inez Mason's brief career as a painter came at the tail end of the second folk art “boom.” Four years before she died, a prolonged stay in the hospital prompted her to start painting. When she returned to her home in Harlem, she was encouraged to pursue the hobby. Her work never received a great deal of renown, but she was included in a number of important group exhibitions.

Anna Mary Robertson (Grandma) Moses (1860-1961) Grandma Moses is the only painter in the current exhibition, and one of a handful from her generation (Morris Hirshfield, John Kane and Horace Pippin are the other three), to receive lasting acclaim. The breadth and complexity of Moses' approach to landscape composition (derived in part from 19th-century popular art, in part from personal observation, and in part from her experience with needlework) and its continuing evolution over the course of her career, make her unique. When she was in her seventies, Moses began creating pictures as gifts for friends and to sell at rural charity affairs. In 1938, an amateur art collector from New York City chanced on her paintings in a local drugstore and became her first patron. He brought her work to the attention of Sidney Janis, who included it in a small private showing at the Museum of Modern Art, and later in They Taught Themselves. From the time of her first one-woman exhibition at the Galerie St. Etienne in 1940, critics and the public recognized a quality in Moses' work that placed it apart from the growing crowd of “primitives” flooding the New York art scene. Few would have predicted that Moses, who was 80 in 1940, would live to have a flourishing career, but she was blessed with exceptional longevity. Gradually, her old age, her homespun personality and the phenomenal appeal of her art combined to give her something of a mythical aura. As other folk painters faded into obscurity, Moses became an international sensation. When she died at the age of 101, the hail of publicity was so great that it triggered a critical backlash. Her achievement, however, was strong enough to withstand this, and it is today finding its true place in the history of 20th-century American folk art.

Nan Phelps (b. 1904) Nan Phelps is the youngest artist in the current exhibition, and belongs with the others only by a degree of association. She has probably been painting all her life—the earliest work here dates from the 1930s. When, in the 1940s, self-taught painters began to receive national publicity, she sought the advice of Dorothy Miller at the Museum of Modern Art. Miller referred her to the Galerie St. Etienne, which was by then well known for its involvement with Grandma Moses. Real success for Phelps, however, did not come until 1981, when her work was included in the exhibition and book The Folk Art Tradition. She has since become something of a local celebrity in the small Ohio community where she lives, and was recently honored by a parade in London, Kentucky, her birthplace. It is important to note that Phelps has kept her work fresh by depicting contemporary subjects, as opposed to the synthetic nostalgia which characterizes much present-day “folk” art.

Fred E. Robertson (1878-1953) It was perhaps inevitable that the success of Grandma Moses would spawn a host of imitators. Because Moses honestly believed that “anyone can paint,” she encouraged other members io her family to take up the brush. The result of their efforts—no better and no worse than most of the pseudo-folk art on the market today—belies Moses' generous philosophy, while simultaneously confirming the uniqueness of her achievement. However, one member of the Moses family did develop an original style. This was Fred Robertson, the artist's brother, who began painting in the 1940s and was given his first exhibition at this gallery in 1945. His works, long overshadowed by that of his famous sister, evidences a somber palette and straightforward compositional approach that are reflective of his apparently dour and down-to-earth personality. His oeuvre, though not large, remains an interesting and increasingly significant footnote in the history of 20th-century folk art.

Ladis Sabo (1870-1953) Ladis Sabo, a Hungarian immigrant who had retired from the clothing industry, first began painting in the early 1940s, stimulated by a paint set his daughter had given him. Like others of his generation, he was encouraged by friends and acquaintances to take his hobby seriously. However, by the time he debuted at the Galerie St. Etienne in 1946, interest in 20th-century folk art was on the wane. One critic went so far as to state: “We are reluctant to praise the policy of any gallery which submits to the present fad of favoring artistic freaks to the detriment of young as well as mature talent, often so desperately in need of attention and promotion.” It is safe to say that Sabo did not flourish in this climate, though for a time his work was routinely included in group exhibitions of naïve art.

Patsy Santo (b. 1893) Patsy Santo pursued a number of professional activities after emigrating to this country from Italy in 1913. He worked for the railroad, for factories, and as a housepainter. His first artistic effort was an outgrowth of one of his housepainting jobs; his second was undertaken at the request of a friend. He did not follow up on these sporadic endeavors until many years later, when one of his paintings took first prize at the 1937 state fair in Rutland, Vermont. This brought Santo his first patron, and inspired him to start painting in earnest. Other exhibitions followed. His introduction to the New York art world was about as auspicious as any folk painter could hope for. He debuted, with Grandma Moses, Morris Hirshfield and a number of others, in a 1939 members-only showing at the Museum of Modern Art. Naturally, Sidney Janis included him in They Taught Themselves, observing that Santo, unlike most painters, evidenced continuing stylistic development. Quite clearly, Santo aspired to academic verisimilitude, and with practice he came close to achieving it. It is easy to understand the instant success accorded his bucolic snow scenes, though some of them can hardly be called true folk art.